Tribute 64 controller review

by Martin Watts, 27 May 2019

Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controllers in red and forest green colours.

Tribute 64 is a fitting name for Retro-bit’s new N64 controller. After all, it’s clearly inspired by none other than the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

It’s a smart move on Retro-bit’s part given just how popular Hori’s dinky pad is with N64 enthusiasts even today.

A comparison shot between the N64 Hori Mini Pad and the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller.

And while the Hori Pad is expensive and difficult to track down, Retro-bit’s homage is affordable and in plentiful supply.

But just how does it compare to the real thing? And what about other controllers, such as the official N64 controller and Retro Fighters’ recent Brawler 64 pad?

Let’s take a closer look.

Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controllers in their original packaging.

Tribute 64 controller – features overview

The Tribute 64 controller is compatible with N64 consoles and has the following features:

  • two-prong design similar to the N64 Hori Mini Pad
  • large GameCube-style joystick
  • two Z buttons – one on each shoulder
  • face-button layout that mimics the official N64 controller
  • memory card and Rumble Pak expansion port
  • three-metre cable
  • currently available in three colours: red, ocean blue and forest green

Retro-bit also plans to release a USB version to use with PC, Mac, Nintendo Switch, and other devices. Note: this review only covers the N64 version.

Comparison photo of the official N64 controller (left) and the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller.

Size, shape and weight

Unsurprisingly, the Tribute 64 looks very similar to the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

However, it’s ever so slightly larger, and the grooves where the prongs meet the base of the controller are less pronounced.

The undersides of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller and the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

Despite its larger size, the Tribute 64 is actually 5g lighter than the Hori Pad, weighing in at 148g (excluding the cable).

It’s a tad heavier than Retro Fighters’ Brawler 64 pad, but still around 40g less than the original N64 controller.

Comparison photo of the Retro Fighters' Brawler 64 controller (left) and the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller (right).

The plastic shell is decent quality, and the transparent colours look especially nice. Not bad for a relatively cheap controller.

The prongs are contoured to wrap your fingers around, and when held this way the Tribute 64 sits snugly in your hands. Your thumbs naturally rest over the joystick and A button in this position.

A photo comparing the shape and size of the Tribute 64 controller and the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

But unless you have very small hands, you’ll find the shoulder buttons sit under the middle of your index fingers.

These buttons are still perfectly usable, but it may take some getting used to.

Holding the Tribute 64 controller for N64 in both hands

Unlike the Hori Pad, the expansion port on the Tribute 64’s underside doesn’t press up against your middle fingers.

The difference is pretty minimal, but players with thicker fingers will likely appreciate the extra space.

A side shot showing how the Tribute 64 rests on top of your middle fingers when held.

Joystick

The Tribute 64’s joystick is very similar to that of Nintendo GameCube controller. It too is rubbery, but the head has a larger diameter.

At first glance it looks almost identical to the N64 Hori Mini Pad’s stick.

Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller's joystick.

However, take a closer look and you’ll see the textured grip lines are more raised and closer together on the Hori Pad. The stick’s also a little taller.

These differences may seem like minor details in the grand scheme of things. But because the Tribute 64’s joystick offers more resistance when pushed, you may find your thumb slips more easily. Especially if your hands tend to get sweaty when playing.

A photo showing the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller's joystick and that of the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

Generally, the stick is a lot more comfortable and durable than the official N64 controller’s. You can put it through its paces in Mario Party‘s stick-spin games or Super Smash Bros. 64 without damaging the stick or your hands.

It also sits in an octagonal gate as per most N64 controllers. However, it doesn’t “lock” into the grooves on the right-hand side like it does on the left for some reason.

Testing the analog stick’s range, precision and sensitivity

I benchmarked the Tribute 64’s joystick range against other N64 controllers using the Compo 2012 NEOFLASH N64 controller test software. You can find the results in the screenshots below:

The Tribute 64 has a much higher deadzone than the official N64 controller (around the 110 mark compared to the original’s max range in the low 80s).

As a result, this pad is a lot more sensitive than the original. You don’t need to push the stick as far before reaching the maximum range virtually all N64 games use.

It comes close to the N64 Hori Mini Pad in terms of performance, although the top-right range is worryingly off. I tested a second Tribute 64 controller and got similar results.

A controller test showing the Tribute 64's upper-right position performing poorly.

Perhaps the right side of the octagonal gate is to blame for this?

The Tribute 64 stick’s extra range isn’t a problem for some types of games, such as 3D platformers.

In fact, it can be advantageous in some instances. For example, you can turn more quickly in some racing games.

Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controllers sitting alongside N64 Hori Mini Pads.

But much like the N64 Hori Mini Pad, the Tribute 64 falls down in games that require very precise control.

It’s difficult, for example, to aim down sights in Perfect Dark or GoldenEye 007. Even pushing the stick very slightly moves the on-screen sight more than you’d expect.

It’s also harder to hold your aim, as the oversensitive nature of the stick causes the sight to jitter.

Forest green and red Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controllers side by side on a table.

Interestingly, this controller fares better than both the Brawler 64 and the Hori Pad in F-Zero X, which seems quite playable.

This could be down to the stick’s higher resistance possibly preventing accidental overturning.

The only way to know whether a game will play well with the Tribute 64 is to try it. Nevertheless, you probably shouldn’t retire your official N64 controller just yet.

Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller with a Rumble Pak inserted.

D-pad

The D-pad is located in the bottom-middle of the Tribute 64’s face. It’s small just like the one on the N64 Hori Mini Pad, but not as raised nor as spongy to press.

As you may have already suspected, the Tribute 64 is not an ideal controller choice for D-pad-heavy games.

For example, the size makes it difficult to pull off accurate directional inputs in fighting games.

Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller D-pad.

It’s also very close to the A button, meaning your thumbs are practically touching when using it.

Still, the location of the D-pad is ideal for games that use it in a secondary capacity.

No longer must you stretch your thumb to reach the D-pad like you had to with the original controller – it’s just right there for you.

Using the D-pad with the A button is impractical on the Tribute 64 controller for N64 by Retro-bit.

Face Buttons

Retro-bit has wisely chosen to mimic the N64 Hori Mini Pad’s button layout for the Tribute 64. This is just as well given the Hori Pad’s layout resemble the official controller’s.

The A, B and C buttons are located in the usual pattern and have a good amount of space between them. They’re all slightly smaller than their equivalents on the original controller and have a similar amount of travel to them.

Face buttons on the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller.

Your thumb doesn’t have to move too far between each one. At the same time, it’s unlikely you’ll accidentally hit the wrong one.

They’re a little bit noisier to press than both the original controller and Hori Pad. But thankfully, they don’t anywhere near as loud as those on the Brawler 64.

Base of the Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller where the D-pad sits.

The start button is larger and slightly more raised too. More importantly, it’s not as close to the B button as it is on the Hori Pad.

So there’s a good chance you won’t hit it by mistake when mashing the B button – something Super Smash Bros. 64 players will no doubt appreciate.

Comparison of Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller and N64 Hori Mini Pad from the top of the controller.

Shoulder buttons and triggers

The Tribute 64 controller has four shoulder buttons: L, R and two Z triggers.

Oddly, they’re the only buttons on the controller to not have an engraved letter on or next to them.

The unmarked shoulder buttons of the Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller compared to the N64 Hori Mini Pad.

L and R are positioned at the top and on opposite sides to one another. Then there’s a Z trigger underneath each one.

The Z triggers are identical in terms of functionality, so which one you use is a matter of preference.

Holding down all four shoulder buttons on the Tribute 64 controller by Retro-bit

If you’re comfortable using your index and middle fingers on the same hand then you can just use one side of the controller.

These triggers curve outwards slightly at the bottom too. As a result, you either press the button fully or just press towards the bottom of it.

You have to press down a tiny bit further than the original pad’s Z trigger, but it’s not enough for it to impact your experience negatively.

Shoulder buttons and cable of the Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller.

Expansion port

You can use Rumble Paks and memory cards with the Tribute 64 controller. I didn’t come across any functionality issues when testing them.

However, it’s worth noting that neither the official Rumble Pak nor Controller Pak sit flush within the port.

N64 memory card just poking out of the expansion port on the Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller.

They sit securely in the slot. It’s just the surrounding plastic doesn’t line up. It’s not a functional issue at all – just something you might notice.

The Tribute 64 isn’t compatible with the Transfer Pak, as Retro-bit has previously stated. The Pak will just about fit into the slot, but it may get stuck. Speaking from personal experience, I recommend you don’t try this.

Rumble Pak inserted into the base of a Close-up shot of the Retro-Bit Tribute 64 controller and jutting out slightly.

Summary

For the most part, the Tribute 64 lives up to its name.

The build and material quality are good. It’s got a nice size to it. And the buttons are generally well placed.

That said, the Tribute 64 does such a good job of copying the N64 Hori Mini Pad that it even shares some of the same flaws.

For example, the D-pad’s small size and central position make it virtually useless as a primary controller input. It’s also far too close to the A button.

Retro-bit Tribute 64 controller - forest green - (For Nintendo 64 version)

And just like the controller it’s based on – and every other aftermarket N64 pad for that matter – its joystick doesn’t come close to the precision and sensitivity of Nintendo’s original. In fact, it even falls short of the Hori Pad.

These are the two biggest flaws with what is otherwise a great pad. And when it costs a fraction of what a Hori Pad does, it’s hard to complain. Not to mention that what the stick lacks in accuracy, it makes up for in durability over the official controller’s joystick.

When it comes to many N64 games, Retro-bit’s new pad is an ideal, affordable alternative.

Just make sure you keep an original controller on hand for the games it doesn’t cope with.